OXO vs. simplehuman: Which Toilet Brush Set is Best?
- Nest Alpha
- 3 hours ago
- 3 min read
As highlighted in our 2025 bathroom decor guide, the secret to a high-end en-suite (UK) or guest bath is removing visual clutter. Traditional plungers and brushes are unhygienic eyesores that ruin the modern interior design of a room.
Whether you are performing a small bathroom remodel or simply trying to optimize a tight floor plan, choosing the right cleaning infrastructure is key. Today, we compare the multi-tasking OXO Good Grips Set and the high-tech simplehuman Magnetic Caddy.
The Cheat Sheet: Quick Comparison
Feature | ||
System Type | Brush & Plunger Combo | Brush Only (Plunger Separate) |
Storage Style | Auto-Open Canister | Magnetic Caddy (Open Back) |
Material | Heavy-Duty Plastic | Stainless Steel & Poly |
Drip Tray | Internal (Ventilated) | High-Aesthetic Basin |
Best For... | Small Bathrooms / Storage | Luxury Decor / High Hygiene |
Price Est. | ~$35 - $45 | ~$25 - $35 |
1. The Space-Saving Pro: OXO Good Grips 2-in-1 Set
OXO is the undisputed volume leader on Amazon (85,000+ Ratings). This set is designed for those who want their utility tools to disappear completely.
Pros:
Dual Infrastructure: This is the big winner for efficiency. It houses both the brush and the heavy-duty plunger in one slim canister, meaning you only have one item on your floor instead of two.
Hands-Free Canister: The door opens automatically when you lift the tool and closes when you replace it. You never have to touch the "dirty" housing.
Toilet Compatibility: The plunger is specifically designed to work with all modern high-efficiency toilets.
Cons:
Footprint: While it saves space by combining tools, the canister is wider than the simplehuman model.
2. The Tech Specialist: Simplehuman Toilet Brush with Caddy
simplehuman targets the homeowner who wants "Invisible Tech" in every corner of their home. This is the essential tool for a high-end minimalist look.
Pros:
Magnetic Collar: A high-strength magnet hooks the brush to the caddy. This allows you to carry both together with one hand without the brush dripping on your clean floors.
Replaceable Heads: Instead of throwing the whole unit away, you can buy affordable replacement heads, making it a sustainable home choice.
Limescale Resistant: The stainless steel rod is treated to resist the limescale and corrosion common in UK and Canadian bathrooms.
Cons:
Plunger Not Included: This model only holds the brush. If you need a plunger, you must purchase the matching simplehuman plunger separately, which doubles the floor footprint.
Critical Decision Guide: Combo Units vs. Individual Tools
Which is better for a small bathroom?
Choose the OXO 2-in-1 if you have Zero Storage. If you don't have a cupboard (UK) or vanity to hide your tools, the OXO canister is the best piece of "Invisible Infrastructure." It keeps everything sanitized and out of sight in one go.
Choose the simplehuman if you prioritize Aesthetic and Hygiene. The magnetic carry system is the gold standard for preventing drips during your weekly deep clean. It is the better choice for a master en-suite where you want a "hotel-style" look.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
Buy the OXO Good Grips If:
You want the most efficient way to store both a brush and a plunger.
You are a Renter or live in an apartment with a tiny bathroom.
You want a proven best-seller with the highest volume of global positive reviews.
Buy the Simplehuman If:
You want a sleek stainless steel finish to match your modern faucets.
You want a "Lifetime Tool" with replaceable cleaning heads.
You prioritize the magnetic "drip-free" carry feature.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Comments